Climate change models point to a possible rise in air temperature, ranging from 2 °C to 4 °C. Global changes will therefore have a particularly pronounced effect on the functioning of shallow water bodies known as peat ponds, i.e., habitats formed after peat extraction in peatlands. However, the extent of this impact is still unknown. The main objective of the study was to determine the impact of water level and water physicochemical properties on the functioning of selected groups of aquatic organisms in peat ponds of different origins. The study was conducted in spring, summer and autumn of the years 2024 and 2025, in 10 peat ponds with different trophic status and typology, located in the Polesie National Park in eastern Poland. Considerable fluctuations in water levels, resulting from a scarcity of precipitation, accelerated the drying out and overgrowth of peat ponds, particularly the alkaline and acidic types. Within the zoocoenotic communities, a significant decline in the abundance of planktonic species and an increase in the abundance of littoral or periphytic species were recorded (F = 6.24, p < 0.015). Regarding trophic structure, an increase in the abundance of mixotrophic species and a decrease in the abundance of top-level predators were observed. Hydrological changes were reflected in an increase in species richness and abundance of communities of organisms with broad ecological tolerance (mainly ciliates), and a decrease in the number of species and abundance of planktonic crustaceans and macroinvertebrates. The RDA model explains over 84% of the total variability, indicating excellent model fit to the data and a strong correlation between environmental variables and species composition. Based on p values, water level, temperature, pH, and COD were selected as significant variables, with conductivity, O2, and Ptot demonstrating less statistical significance. Peat ponds ecosystems can serve as an excellent model system for studying the impact of intensifying climate change on the functioning of shallow water bodies.